Assessment: I need an SUV that drives like a efficiency automotive. What do you suggest? | Jobi Cool

The 2021 Genesis GV70 is snug and classy.Mark Richardson/The Globe and Mail

I’ve a 2018 Audi S5 with 33,000 kilometers on it. That is my fifth Audi in a row, after an A8, S4, S6, and SQ5, however I need to strive one thing else.

The S5 is a pleasant automotive, however I get uninterested in trying on the door handles of different vehicles round me. The SQ5 solely lasted 6 weeks – I did not just like the excessive heart of gravity and bumpy, truck-like experience. The supplier was very happy to take it again and promote me the S5.

I am hoping to purchase an electrical automotive, however the vary I would like is not accessible now or within the subsequent three years, so I am contemplating the Genesis G80/GV80 or possibly the brand new Porsche Macan T.

What would you suggest?Frank

Petrina Gentile: Frank has nice style in vehicles. And he does not appear to be driving a lot at simply 33,000 kilometers on an nearly five-year-old automotive.

Mark Richardson: Properly, he has a style for Audis, anyway. They’re very sporty vehicles and rewarding to drive, however not cheaper than BMWs and Mercedes.

Gentiles: Earlier than we get to the opposite German manufacturers, let’s discuss Genesis, from South Korean automaker Hyundai Auto Group.

Richardson: Genesis has pulled out all of the stops with its new autos. It has to – it is a five-year-old firm and it must make impression towards stiff competitors. I’d positively suggest both the G80 sedan or GV80 SUV, however Frank must determine. He does not need to sit decrease and have a look at doorknobs, however he does not need to sit increased and have a better heart of gravity, both. He does not need an electrical automotive, which has a decrease heart of gravity, so which is it to be?

Gentiles: We do not know Frank’s age, but when he is over 50, I say go for the GV80 SUV and even the GV70, the smaller SUV, from Genesis. It’s snug, trendy and has an important experience and dealing with.

Richardson: I additionally recommend the smaller GV70, because it has a sportier really feel to its dealing with. I am unsure why Frank thinks the Audi SQ5 drives like a truck, however I feel he is a choosy driver and arduous to please. Nonetheless – it is his cash.

Gentiles: The GV70 is enjoyable to drive; I feel he’ll prefer it higher than the SQ5. And I like Genesis’ enterprise mannequin – mounted automotive costs and a few upkeep, like oil modifications, are included in the price. However we do not know the place Frank lives. That might be a problem for servicing, proper?

Richardson: If he is close to an Audi dealership, he is most likely close to a Genesis dealership. He will get complimentary service and upkeep for 5 years, with free assortment and supply if he lives inside about 50 kilometers of a dealership. That is one of many nice perks of the model. He cannot get that with Porsche.

Gentiles: No, he will not. However what occurs if he does not dwell inside 50 kilometers of a Genesis retailer?

Richardson: He nonetheless will get free upkeep and every thing else – he simply does not get free assortment and supply, so he has to drive himself to the shop, like all the opposite manufacturers. It began as a result of Genesis was initially serviced by Hyundai dealerships and the premium model did not need its clients to go to a Hyundai dealership. It was so common, that it’s nonetheless accessible in new and devoted Genesis shops.

Gentiles: And extra Genesis shops are popping up throughout the nation. Hopefully, she lives close to one to benefit from the red-carpet service. Porsche doesn’t provide that service. However we must always speak concerning the Macan T, which can be on Frank’s record.

Richardson: The Macan is Porsche’s least costly new automotive, and the T is a well-executed variant that begins at $70,800, which is about $5,000 above the bottom worth. Have you ever ever pushed?

Gentiles: I have not pushed the T model, which is new for 2023. However I’ve pushed the Macan base, S and GTS fashions. And the GTS, specifically, is a superb experience. It has true Porsche driving dynamics – it is quick, energetic and one of many sportiest SUVs in the marketplace. Frank will find it irresistible. It’s similar to his Audi SQ5.

Richardson: The GTS has an even bigger and extra highly effective engine, and begins at $92,900. The T is sort of 60 kilograms lighter, so it does not want all of the horsepower of the GTS for a satisfying experience. I can suggest it as an important automotive, however Frank must check drive one for himself to determine which Macan variant he likes, and which he can afford.

The 2023 Alfa Romeo Stelvio has glorious efficiency and dealing with.Handouts

Gentiles: Is there one other automobile that Frank may not have considered?

Richardson: Properly, I am certain he checked out BMW and Mercedes-Benz, however this is one out of left subject – what concerning the Alfa Romeo Stelvio? It is quick, it is not overpriced, it is beautiful to drive, and it is form of quirky. I drove the Veloce version, which begins at round $65,000, and it may possibly hit all of Frank’s fussy buttons.

Gentiles: The Stelvio is commonly neglected within the class, however it’s a blast to drive with nice efficiency and dealing with. I drove it via the well-known Stelvio move in northern Italy and when cornering, the steering was exact and the SUV was nimble and balanced.

Richardson: Its closest competitor is the Porsche Macan, so it ought to positively be thought-about instead. I desire the Macan as a result of I assumed the Stelvio’s cabin was uninteresting, however Frank may prefer it. It provides some Italian aptitude to a section dominated by German makers.

Gentiles: I like the outside styling on the Stelvio and you will not see a lot on the street in comparison with the Macan. However I desire the cabin within the Macan. The Stelvio’s know-how and infotainment system are outdated in comparison with the competitors.

Richardson: It is positively bizarre. The starter button on the left aspect of the steering wheel caught me each time I reached for it within the fallacious place.

Gentiles: So what’s your high suggestion for Frank?

Richardson: He’ll most likely like all three, however the Genesis GV70 is the very best worth, the Porsche Macan T is the favored alternative, and the Alfa Romeo Stelvio is the decide if Frank desires to face out from the gang.

Gentiles: Frank, go for the Genesis GV70 – that is my high decide for its efficiency, model and worth.

The 2023 Porsche Macan T has a four-cylinder turbo engine that produces 261 horsepower.Jeremy Sinek / The Globe and Mail

What automotive do you have to purchase? Write to Mark and Petrina at and use ‘What automotive’ as a part of your topic line. Emails with completely different topic traces is probably not answered.

Purchasing for a brand new automotive? See what’s new Globe Drive Construct and Value Software to seek out the newest reductions, rebates and charges on new vehicles, vans and SUVs. Press right here to get your worth.

Supply hyperlink